Re-read: The Penderwicks series

The final book in The Penderwicks series was released just last week. I haven’t read it yet, but I intend to. So, while I wait to get my hands on the book, I decided to do a re-read of the other four books. Here are my thoughts…

**Note: This blog post MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS. However, I have tried my best to keep things vague enough so that, in case you haven’t the books, there aren’t horrible secrets revealed.**

Book #1 // The Penderwicks

penderwicks1This is the book that starts it all. It’s highly inspired by Little Women and actually feels like it takes place in the past. (Although, Mr. Penderwick does have a computer, which tells us it is supposed to be happening in our present.)

We begin with the family, lost on their way to Arundel, where they are to spend their summer vacation. We meet Roselind, Skye, Jane, and Batty. (And there’s Mr. Penderwick, a head-in-the-clouds botanist who likes to quote phrases in Latin.) And it isn’t long before we get to meet Jeffrey, son of Mrs. Tiften, the owner of Arundel. Then we have some wonderful adventures, including a stand-off with a bull, missing bunny-rabbits, and a rope ladder that leads to Jeffrey’s bedroom.

One of the things I love about books like this is how it references other books. Like the whole “Penderwick family honor” thing. That’s a reference to the (motherless) Bastable children in E. Nesbit’s The Treasure Seekers who are seeking to restore their own family’s honour. Birdsall does put her own spin on things. I love the Penderwicks’ little rituals and code words. The MOPS (Meeting of Penderwick Sisters), MOOPS (Meeting of Older Penderwick Sisters), and the OAP (Oldest Available Penderwick) who’s supposed to keep an eye out for Batty.

On this re-read, the one thing I noticed is the vilification of Mrs. Tifton (and it extends to the other books as well!). Even before we meet Mrs. Tifton, she has a bad name… Harry the Tomato Man calls her “snooty as all get-out.” But we know that she loves Jeffrey. In fact, even though she has a hard time listening to Jeffrey, ultimately she does do what is best for him. BUT, for some reason, she is HATED throughout the books.

I mean ALL the books.

None of the kids like her at all. I wish Jeanne Birdsall had been a little more grey in her depiction. Not that Mrs. Tiften couldn’t be a source of friction. There are some wonderful moments where she obviously gets their names wrong (which shows us that she isn’t really paying attention to the children, even when they correct her). However this ends up as a bit of a plot hole when she greatly insults Roselind regarding Cagney. (From what I’ve been led to believe, I’m surprised Mrs. T even paid enough attention to notice!)

Here’s what I wish… Could Birdsall not have given her redemption in some way? Even if just for Jeffrey’s sake. (At least something to extend to the other books where she isn’t the primary antongist?)

My only other beef with this book (and with the next two books) is Sabrina Starr. I can’t stand Sabrina Starr! Come to think of it, Jane should be my favourite character, since I am drawn to writers (like Jo March). BUT, Jane’s creation of Sabrina Starr irks me. So. Much. And thus, so does Jane. (Sorry, Jane!)

Overall, I love the timeless quality of this book that starts it all. It gave me that feeling of reading Little Women, or Anne of Green Gables, or The Secret Garden or The Treasure Seekers… all books written 100+ years ago! I love the bond between the sisters. Really and truly, I found this book as much as a delight to read as the first time around.

A Favourite Quote from the Book

This book is set on the grounds of Arundel, a beautiful, stately home with wonderful gardens.

On one side of the property, a high stone wall separated the cottage from its neighbors. Along the front and the other side ran a boundary hedge. Skye knew that Mrs. Tifton’s gardens were beyond that hedge. She could walk back up the driveway and through the break in the hedge. Boring, and likely to lead to being caughtit’s hard to hide on a driveway. Or she could crawl through the hedge and emerge in some sheltered garden nook where neither Mrs. Tifton nor anyone else would be likely to see her.

Definitely option two, Skye decided.

The Penderwicks (Chapter 2)

Book #2 // The Penderwicks on Gardam Street

penderwicks2The main story revolves around the Save Daddy Plan. In this book, we get a prologue where we learn that Mrs. Penderwick (who died of cancer shortly after Batty’s birth) has put in place a plan (with the help of Aunt Claire) to get Mr. Penderwick a new wife. This idea horrifies Roselind and she and her sisters go to some length to save their father from their aunt who is trying to get her brother (Mr. P) on some blind dates.

This book takes place at the Penderwicks’ home during the school year. If you’re expecting Jeffrey, he does come into the book, sort of. Instead, we get to know the neighbours across the street: Tommy and Nick Geiger. (They’ll play bigger roles later in the series.)

The plot is all about little deceptions. First we have Roselind and Tommy, who won’t admit their feelings to each other. Then there’s the story of Jane and Skye flipping homework assignments. Jane writes a play for Skye called Sisters and Sacrifice (with Skye as the supposed playwright). But then Skye gets the surprise of her life when her teacher wants present “Skye’s play”, with her in the leading role! Hilarity ensues. Ultimately, this all comes back to Mr. Penderwick’s own little deception.

Which brings me to Marianne.

Yes, when Mr. Penderwick tells the girls about how he is seeing Marianne, I remember guessing right away what was happening here. When Aunt Claire asks Marianne’s last name, he definitely gives it away. (At least to an adult’s eyes.) Although, for some reason Aunt Claire doesn’t get the reference. (And I’m surprised the girls don’t do a search online and figure it out. But, although we do live in a modern world that includes laptops, these girls don’t seem to know about Google…)

Ah, yes. We get a little Parent Trap in this book… (I love The Parent Trap, so this isn’t a problem for me!)

A Favourite Quote from the Book

In this scene, Mr. Penderwick is about to go on his second blind date, which has been set up by the girls as part of the Save Daddy Plan. (They are attempting to give him such awful dates that he’ll want to quit dating forever.)

“What did Daddy say in Latin, Skye? Mendax, mendax—?”

Skye was relieved. Latin was easier than feelings. “Mendax, mendax, bracae tuae con—something.”

Conflagrant, I think,” said Rosalind, flipping pages. “I’ll start with mendax. M-e-n-d-e-x. It means liar. Daddy called me a liar!”

“You’d just told him his tie looked great.”

The Penderwicks on Gardam Street (Chapter 9)

Book #3 // The Penderwicks at Point Mouette

penderwicks3In this book, Skye is the OAP… the Oldest Available Penderwick. In fact, I can almost see Birdsall saying to herself… Hmm, how do we get Skye to go crazy in this book? Well, let’s make her the OAP. Let’s get rid of the parents (and baby Ben). Let’s take Roselind out of the picture (by sending her to New Jersey). We’ll have to put an adult in (Aunt Claire), but we’ll take her out as soon as we can (with a badly sprained ankle). Let’s get rid of Skye’s special list of instructions (on how to take care of Batty). And bam! Skye’s in a perfect storm for a meltdown.

Like the first book, this is another vacation book. But the absence of Roselind does make things a little more chaotic. One of the funniest parts comes at the beginning before they even leave. Roselind is giving instructions about taking care of Batty. “Rule Five: Batty wears this [life preserver] whenever she’s near the ocean.” Skye points out that since they’re staying on the coast, Batty will ALWAYS be near the ocean. “Then she will always wear it,” insists Roselind. AND the younger Penderwicks (including Batty) completely accept this!

Skye is my favourite Penderwick, so I really did like this book. I loved seeing her stretched to her limit and how she manages to survive her OAP-hood.

By the way, Jeffrey’s back in this book! We see a beautiful mentorship begin between him and Batty as they discover that Batty is actually musical. I love how nobody (in the Penderwick family) believes this musicality is even possible since nobody else in the family has the talent for music. But Jeffrey and Batty have a surprise up their sleeve.

And, come to think of it, so does Birdsall, with regards to the neighbour, Alex. (Although, again, I remember guessing fairly early on, even on my first re-through, what was going to happen.)

Fortunately, this is the final time Sabrina Starr comes into the books. (Unless she makes an appearance in the final book, which I have yet to read.) I still can’t stand Sabrina Starr!

A Favourite Quote from the Book

In this scene, Jane is trying to write her first book about romance. But, she realizes that she has no experience with romance. So, she comes up with a Love Survey…

“Do you believe in love at first sight?” she asked out loud.

“Jane, what are you talking about?” It was Skye again, but this time she was only a few feet away. Jane had caught up without noticing.

“She wants to know if we believe in love at first sight,” said Jeffrey.

“More love,” said Skye, now hitting Jane with the paper towels. “As the OAP, I demand you don’t mention love for the whole rest of the day.”

The Penderwicks at Point Mouette (Chapter 5)

Book #4 // The Penderwicks in Spring

penderwicks4 Fast forward several years. When I first read this book, it took me awhile to realize that quite a few years had passed since the events of the previous book. (The one set at Point Mouette.)

In fact, in this book, the three oldest Penderwicks are hardly in it. I mean, they are, but they are not the protagonists. Actually, Skye (my favourite!) has the role of sort-of antagonist in this book. :/

Instead, Batty is the now “oldest” along with brother Ben, and little sister, Lydia. She starts a dog-walking business to help pay for singing lessons. Except the singing lessons are a secret, one she’s not even ready to share with Ben!

Batty and Ben have a nice relationship going. Batty is excitedly awaiting her birthday, but her older sisters make life difficult. Roselind brings home some crazy boyfriend from college. Skye is angry with Jeffrey and won’t let him come visit, much to Batty’s disappointment. And then Batty overhears something that throws her into turmoil.

One of the stars of this book is the neighbour, Nick Geiger. He’s home, on leave from the Army. He’s sports-crazy, but surprisingly he has a wonderful bond with Batty (who has NO interest in sports, whatsoever!) And, to tell you the truth, I think his character has developed much more than Tommy. Or even Jeffrey, at this point!

(Hooray! Sabrina Starr is gone!)

A Favourite Quote from the Book

This is a conversation between Batty and Ben, two of the “younger” Penderwicks (not including 2-year-old Lydia).

But Batty was already blocking the door again, wedging a chair under the doorknob. Then she turned down the music so that they could better hear each other. “I’m glad you’re here. I’m calling a MOYPS.”

“Another one? we just had one.”

… “MOYPS come to

“What about Lydia? She should be here if it’s a meeting of the younger Penderwicks.”

“This is really just for you. We’ll call it a MOBAB, Meeting of Batty and Ben, okay? Please?”

The Penderwicks in Spring (Chapter 18)

Book #5 // The Penderwicks at Last

penderwicks5And this brings me to the final book… which I haven’t read yet.

I don’t know if I’m setting myself up for disappointment… Perhaps. I don’t always like final books in series. So, I’m trying not to think too much about what this book might be about. (I have my suspicions about what she’s going to do.)

The only thing I will say here is that I really like how they designed all the covers for the series. The silhouettes are beautiful. I think perhaps that is partly what helps give the books their old-fashioned feel.


Have you read these books? Which Penderwick is your favourite? Do you hate Sabrina Starr as much as I do? (Or, maybe you love Sabrina Starr!) I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments! (And if you’ve already read The Penderwicks at Last, please don’t give me any spoilers!)

24 thoughts on “Re-read: The Penderwicks series

  1. I actually like Sabrina Starr. I think she’s hilarious. I also love Jane’s zany comments and randomness. That said, I understand how Sabrina Starr could be annoying. It is a bit much in parts.
    As for my favorite Penderwicks? It’s split between Skye and Jane.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m glad Sabrina Starr has a champion to defend her! Jane would be pleased. 🙂

      And you’re right that Jane’s zany comments and randomness make her an appealing character. I do like her for that! And I do love the fact that Jane loves books!!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This post reminds me that I read the first one ages ago, liked it, and then never read the others! I’ve been lagging in my reading of middle grade books so I will try this series again. I probably need to reread the first one, ha ha!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I grew up with these books (I was about seven when I read the first two) and I’ve been awaiting this final book for so long. I’ve always loved all the books (my mother died of cancer when I was 11, and they helped me heal from that loss, deal with my father’s dating, love my new stepmom, and accept the prospect of an upcoming half-sibling) so I’m probably pretty biased–in fact, I’d never dreamed of criticizing anything about them until recently. This was a great post, and I wanted to offer the perspective of someone who read these as a child:
    1) Your point about the one-dimensional treatment of Mrs. Tifton is good, but I think it’s worth saying that compared to other children’s book villains, she’s pretty nuanced, in that she has good motivations for her villainy. I remember reading the first book as a child and being a bit troubled by the fact that the “bad guy” loved Jeffrey so much–I wanted to make her a monster. Of course, on reflection, she isn’t as complex of a character as she seemed back then, but the fact that her motivations are good does add depth. Also, it was Birdsall’s first book, so I’m inclined to show her some grace there.
    2) Sabrina Starr is a little irritating, I agree, but I’m kind of glad she is. Jane is a child, and all writers write super-cringey things as children. I looked up to Jane for a lot of my childhood, and she helped me love writing. Now, I have a more Skye-like reaction to her (I love her but she bugs me), but I can still appreciate her. I also love the fact that she’s an extroverted bookworm, because that is a very rare combination in kid lit.
    3) The Marianne plot twist in Gardam Street came as a complete surprise to me when I was seven. Of course if I were to read it now, I’d see through it in a heartbeat because I’m familiar with Sense and Sensibility, but it was such a plot twist back then!
    Goodness, this is quite long. I really enjoyed this post, and thank you for offering your perspective on them!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks so much for commenting! I love that this book was a part of your way of processing grief. Wow! (If I were Jeanne Birdsall, that would be the BEST compliment ever.)

      I sometimes wonder when I read a book like this what my reaction would be if I were a child. Thanks for adding your two cents!

      Re: Sabrina Starr. I can handle her in the first three books (because, as you said, Jane is a child). I’m so glad that by Book 4, Jane has outgrown Sabrina Starr. And yes, it’s great to get the extroverted bookworm.

      Re: Marianne. Yes, I could see a child NOT connecting the dots with regards to Marianne. I think I wish she (Birdsall) had made it a little less obvious. Like maybe NOT giving us Marianne’s last name. (I mean, when he tells them, Aunt Claire’s right there. I’m really surprised Aunt Claire doesn’t catch on!)

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oh yes, I’ve wondered that about Aunt Claire–has she just never come in contact with Sense and Sensibility? It’s a bit of a plot hole, haha. Also I recently realized that Marianne is like 16 years old, which has cast the whole thing in a strange light, but I suppose it’s best if I don’t think about it too hard 😉

        Liked by 1 person

  4. I love this series so much : ) I read the last book in less than a day; I do feel like it could have ended better. Everything does come full circle though. There’s still a feeling of sadness that the series is over

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I absolutely adore the Penderwicks! Each time I reread then they seem to get better and better. You’re right, they definitely have a Little Women feel to them.
    I can’t decide who my favorite sister is, but I love how Birdsall draws out all of their personalities. She’s a wonderful author!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. This post made me so happy to read! I love The Penderwicks dearly.❤️The connection between the sisters, and (like you said) the way it is set both in the present but in the past, and all their traditions makes for a wonderful read. It just fills me with such a happy and full feeling whenever I think about it.

    I had no idea there was a last book! I thought the Penderwicks in Spring was the last one. Now I’m looking forward to reading it, although I’m a little sad it’s the last one. I hope all the loose ends get tied up and it’s ended perfectly!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I love the Penderwicks! I have read and own all the books, even the new one! Batty is my favorite Penderwick and I love the way Mr. Penderwick speaks Latin! I miss Hound Penderwick, but there is a new dog in the story with three legs ~ Hatch! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I had no clue there were so many Penderwicks books. I really need to read this series! I love that you compared it to Little Women, as that’s one of my favorite novels.

    So I would like to invite you to my L. M. Alcott reading challenge this June! We’re talking about all things Alcott and everyone gets to choose a book(s) to read for the challenge — whatever you want it to be, concerning Miss Alcott (+ there’s a giveaway!) Details are on my blog…


    Liked by 1 person

    • I hope you get a chance to read the Penderwicks! The books are each good in their own way 🙂

      I will check out your blog. I don’t know if I have the time this month to participate in another reading challenge. But I’ll drop by and maybe add my two cents if I can.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s